An ex gratia payment doesn’t require the insurer to admit it’s liable for a loss or imply that the insurer’s payout was legally obligated. It’s strictly a voluntary payment made by the insurance company, sometimes to cut its losses or to maintain your business.
How an Ex Gratia Payment Works
An ex gratia payment is different from a traditional claim payment because it’s a payout that you aren’t eligible for based on the terms of your policy. For example, let’s say that you’ve been a loyal customer of your home insurance company for years. You thought you had the water coverage you needed in place via your flood insurance coverage. But then a sewer line backs up and causes flooding in your home. You’re surprised to learn your policy doesn’t cover this damage because the sewer backup wasn’t caused by a flood. You think your policy should cover the damage. But the specific terms don’t cover this type of flood damage. Because the insurer doesn’t want to lose your business, it may decide to send you an ex gratia payment to help cover some of your loss. In this example, the insurance company had no obligation to give you anything. However, it decided to do so as a kindness to help a loyal customer during a challenging period.
Why Do Ex Gratia Payments Exist?
If your claim is denied based on your policy terms, the insurance company isn’t required to pay you anything. However, there are a few reasons why the insurance company may opt to voluntarily send you an ex gratia payment to help you with your loss:
If you file a lawsuit and the insurance company thinks it will cost more to go to court and fight the claim, it may opt to send you this payment instead. This decision helps the insurer save money. Similarly, if your policy language is ambiguous and there’s a reasoned argument from an insurance coverage counsel, your insurer might decide to pay part or all of the claim to avoid going to court. The insurance company is worried about losing your business, especially if you’re a long-term customer who pays large premiums. The insurance company doesn’t want to lose this business, so to encourage you to stick around, it may make a voluntary payment to show goodwill.
Ex gratia payments don’t happen only in the insurance industry. An employer may give these voluntary funds as a part of a severance package, and the government also has been known to pay them. No matter which organization pays them, ex gratia payments are a way of showing kindness or goodwill to someone.
What Do Ex Gratia Payments Mean for You?
Even if an insurer denies your claim, there is a chance that you still may receive funds from your insurance company in this way. However, because these payments aren’t legally required, you shouldn’t count on one to help compensate for your losses. Instead, it’s much better to have the proper amounts and types of insurance in place so that any claims go through as expected. In some parts of the world, ex gratia payments have tax implications. If you get one from your insurance company, it’s worth checking with a tax accountant to make sure you know what (if any) taxes you’ll need to pay on it.
